Tonawanda Elementary School

Tonawanda Elementary educates around 525 inquisitive learners from pre-K to grade 5 with a dedicated crew of about 33 full-time teachers—while the student/teacher ratio is 16:1, the school itself provides students a very cozy experience. Academic performance shows that 82% of students are proficient in math and 77% in reading.

The student population of Tonawanda is White (about 82%), while the representation of Asian (~5%), Hispanic (~5%), Black (~2%), and multiracial students (~6%) is increasing. Tonawanda has an excellent DPI rating of 88.1.

Under the leadership of Principal Alexis Kasmarick, families will find a school rich with STEAM and gifted programming, tucked away along the tree-lined streets of Elm Grove. Those interested in the neighborhood will find a challenging housing market with the median home sale in Elm Grove sitting at approximately $573K. Overall, Tonawanda feels successful, welcoming, and grounded in everyday community life, making it one of the best elementary schools for your child.

Tonawanda Elementary School successfully ran a cultural fair event that celebrates diversity and inclusion. Future events will include a science expo and a family fitness night with the purpose of fostering connections as a community, and creating opportunities for students to reflect on their well-being.

1. What is the student-to-teacher ratio at Tonawanda Elementary School?

The student-to-teacher ratio at Tonawanda Elementary is 15:1, which is higher than the 13:1 Wisconsin state average.

2. How representative of the state as a whole is the student enrollment at Tonawanda Elementary?

Tonawanda Elementary's minority student enrollment is 18%, comprised mainly of Hispanic and Asian students.

3. What are the proficiency rates at the school in core academic areas?

In the Forward Exam, Tonawanda Elementary students score consistently above district and state averages, with over 70% of students proficient or higher in English Language Arts and grades 3-5, and over 75% proficient or higher in Math.

4. What is the school's overall testing rank?

Tonawanda Elementary ranks in the top 1% for 2025 and excels in academic performance.

5. How many total students are enrolled in Tonawanda Elementary?

Tonawanda Elementary has a total enrollment of around 525 students.